With Spain main shark fishing and the manufacturing of unprocessed shark fins in Europe, Spanish MEPs took distance from their respective political teams and stood towards a residents’ petition calling for a ban on the commerce of fins.
On Thursday (11 Could), EU lawmakers debated in plenary the European Residents Initiative (ECI) ‘Cease Finning – Cease the commerce’ – signed by over 1,000,000 individuals – which calls on the Fee to suggest measures to ban the commerce of free shark and ray fins within the EU.
Finning refers to reducing off the fins of sharks – and more and more different species – earlier than throwing the physique again into the ocean.
In accordance with figures introduced within the ECI, round 73 million sharks die solely for his or her fins yearly, although the precise quantity stays speculative due to the “lack of dependable knowledge and the extraordinarily excessive worldwide variety of unreported circumstances of unlawful fishing.”
Within the EU, this follow has been banned since 2013, and all boats should land fins naturally hooked up to the animals. Nonetheless, fins can nonetheless be transported and traded afterwards with out being hooked up to the remainder of the physique.
“The issue is just not the act of finning alone, it’s the legality of the free shark fin commerce,” stated Stefanie Brendl, Brussels consultant for the ECI.
“Similar to the ivory commerce, it’s the product that’s driving the overfishing” and “hindering international shark conservation targets,” she stated.
Asger Christensen, liberal MEP and vice-chair of the fisheries committee, sided with the residents’ petition and highlighted the “want to ban the commerce of shark fins and the transhipment, import and export” of those, including that he took the initiative to the fisheries committee.
Spaniards go solo
However the subject has sparked discomfort amongst some lawmakers, particularly Spanish members of main political events, who’ve repeatedly said that the fleets don’t interact in finning practices and that there isn’t any ‘darkish market’ of fins.
Izaskun Bilbao, Spanish MEP additionally from the liberal Renew get together, differed from his colleague’s method and stated that the ECI “brings nothing new to the sustainability of the practices of the European fleet.”
“Quite the opposite,” she stated, “it brings new restrictions to the professionals within the sector, which is able to result in larger ranges of strain on the species from different fleets that follow finning.”
Likewise, socialist Spanish MEP Clara Aguilera stated this initiative is “pointing in an odd course” as a result of finning is already banned.
“We can’t ban fin commerce once you catch the entire piece,” she added, “however what the Fee may do is to defend that different nations ban finning too,” in addition to “an enough traceability of the merchandise.”
However different members of the socialist group, comparable to Croatian MEP Predrag Fred Matić, said {that a} “authorized marketplace for shark fins opens the market to unlawful fins as a result of it’s actually troublesome to establish their origin.”
Spanish inexperienced MEP Ana Miranda didn’t touch upon the ban, in contrast to others in her group who have been essential of fin commerce.
Miranda defended that the Galician fleet “doesn’t follow finning” and that any suspicion across the Galician provide chain concerned in finning is “false and unfair,” including “there isn’t any darkish fin market from Vigo [Galicia] to Asia.”
Nonetheless, her French colleague Caroline Roose stated the EU is killing “very massive numbers of sharks to feed the fin commerce, scorning the results for biodiversity.”
The EU, a serious participant
General, “the EU is a serious participant within the fin commerce, catching sharks in all elements of the globe and supplying the markets in Hong Kong SAR, Singapore and Taiwan province the place an estimated greater than 50% of the worldwide shark fin commerce passes,” stated the ECI Brussels consultant.
Brendl added import numbers in Asia are reducing “aside from the EU fleets, which have elevated.” The EU at present makes up for 45% of fins exported to Asian markets.
In accordance with the ECI organisers, Spain has the most important marketplace for shark meat and is the main nation for shark fishing in Europe.
In 2016, Spain caught virtually 40 tones of blue shark within the North Atlantic, South Atlantic and Mediterranean – very removed from the closest competitor, Portugal, with barely over 13 tonnes.
Steve Trent, CEO of the campaigning group Environmental Justice Basis which helps the ECI, stated the EU can’t “ignore its personal involvement of their [shark fins] commerce.”
“The EU ought to work with third nations to finish shark finning” and “take away itself from the fin commerce now to make sure credibility and sustainability,” he stated.
An official response from the Fee to the ECI is predicted by July 2023.
Within the meantime, fisheries Commissioner Virginijus Sinkevičius acknowledged that “there’s a international downside with sharks, and we must always take our tasks.”
“The EU place must be geared increasingly at persevering with to be a part of the answer slightly than changing into a part of the issue or staying silent as an observer,” he stated on the finish of the controversy.
[Edited by Gerardo Fortuna/Alice Taylor]
Learn extra with EURACTIV
